St Ives is the most extreme property market in Cornwall. Average sold prices in TR26 are ~£475,000 — roughly 13× local median earnings, the worst affordability ratio in the South West outside parts of Salcombe and Padstow. Downalong cottages with sea views routinely exceed £700k; Carbis Bay detached homes push £900k+.
The market is shaped by two unique constraints. First, the 2016 Neighbourhood Plan Section 106 restricts all new-build housing to principal-residence use only. Second, the 200% second-home council tax premium (April 2025) and the planned short-term let licensing regime have cooled the pure investor segment. The result: existing holiday-let stock is scarcer and more valuable, while new-build pricing has compressed.
Watch points: Section 106 enforcement means many high-street lenders simply won't lend on post-2016 builds; listed building densityin Downalong creates surveyor headaches; and access(no off-street parking, narrow lanes, pedestrian-only streets) is a recurring lender concern.